The Toronto Blue Jays are about to get a significant boost this week with the return of outfielder Daulton Varsho. Varsho, known for his elite defense, left-handed bat, and versatility, immediately strengthens the roster — but it also creates a dilemma. With the outfield already jammed with contributors, someone is going to lose their spot.
And in my view, the choice is clear.
When Varsho rejoins the team, Toronto will be juggling outfielders like Kevin Kiermaier, George Springer, Davis Schneider, Cavan Biggio (in a hybrid role), and utility options capable of playing the corners. While Springer and Kiermaier are entrenched veterans — one a franchise face, the other a Gold Glove mainstay — the bottom half of the depth chart is where the decision gets interesting.
My pick for demotion: Davis Schneider.
Yes, Schneider has been a spark plug at times, especially with his bat, but the overall numbers have cooled dramatically. His average has dipped, the strikeouts have piled up, and defensively, he doesn’t offer the same range or reliability as Varsho, Kiermaier, or even Biggio. In a playoff hunt where every defensive misplay could swing a series, the Jays can’t afford to carry a liability in the field — even one who offers occasional pop at the plate.
Demoting Schneider (likely to Triple-A Buffalo) would allow him to get consistent at-bats, regain his timing, and be ready when the Blue Jays inevitably need reinforcements again. It’s a move that protects the outfield’s defensive integrity without completely closing the door on his major league contributions later in the season.
If the Blue Jays are serious about winning tight, low-scoring games — and with their offense still unpredictable, they should be — then prioritizing defense and versatility is the way forward. Daulton Varsho fits that mold perfectly, and there’s no question he’ll be a major piece down the stretch.
Toronto faces a tough choice this week, but if they’re thinking clearly, Schneider is the one who should make way for Varsho’s return.
Leave a Reply