As the offseason churns forward, the New York Mets find themselves at a critical juncture regarding their franchise cornerstone, Pete Alonso. Rumors of Alonso’s potential departure—either through a blockbuster trade or as part of a broader roster overhaul—have left Mets fans and the organization contemplating life without their star slugger. Amid this uncertainty, one intriguing name has emerged as a possible replacement: Detroit Tigers infielder Spencer Torkelson.
Why Torkelson?
Torkelson, the former No. 1 overall pick in the 2020 MLB Draft, represents an enticing option for the Mets. At just 25 years old, he’s coming off a breakout season with the Tigers, where he showcased his raw power, hitting 31 home runs with 94 RBIs. While his .233 batting average leaves room for improvement, Torkelson’s advanced plate discipline and ability to drive the ball make him a promising long-term asset.
The Mets, under the leadership of new general manager David Stearns, are looking to build a younger, more sustainable core. Torkelson’s age, team control through 2028, and upside align perfectly with this vision.
The Pete Alonso Dilemma
Pete Alonso’s status as one of the premier power hitters in baseball is undisputed. Since debuting in 2019, Alonso has been a consistent offensive force, delivering multiple 40+ home run seasons. However, with Alonso set to become a free agent after the 2025 season and likely commanding a contract north of $200 million, the Mets face a tough decision.
Retaining Alonso would mean committing significant financial resources to a player entering his 30s. On the other hand, moving on from Alonso—particularly if a lucrative trade offer materializes—could help replenish the Mets’ farm system while freeing up payroll flexibility.
What Would It Take to Land Torkelson?
Acquiring Torkelson won’t be easy. The Tigers view him as a key part of their rebuilding efforts, and prying him away would likely require a substantial offer. The Mets might need to include a combination of top prospects like Luisangel Acuña, Kevin Parada, or Jett Williams, along with a controllable major-league arm such as David Peterson or Tylor Megill.
While this price tag may seem steep, the Mets’ deep-pocketed ownership under Steve Cohen gives them the latitude to take calculated risks in pursuit of a brighter future. Additionally, Torkelson’s long-term potential could outweigh the cost of parting with top-tier talent.
Is Torkelson a Fit?
Defensively, Torkelson has proven capable at first base, posting above-average metrics in 2024. His transition to Citi Field, a more pitcher-friendly park than Detroit’s Comerica Park, could slightly temper his power numbers but should still allow him to thrive as a middle-of-the-order threat.
Moreover, Torkelson’s makeup and leadership qualities—traits often highlighted during his rise through the Tigers’ system—would help him navigate the bright lights and intense scrutiny of New York.
The Bigger Picture
The Mets’ pursuit of Spencer Torkelson signals a willingness to make bold moves in reshaping their roster. While losing a fan favorite like Alonso would be a seismic shift, targeting a young, controllable player like Torkelson underscores the organization’s commitment to building a sustainable contender.
As the hot stove continues to heat up, all eyes will remain on Queens. Whether Alonso stays or goes, one thing is certain: the Mets’ front office is leaving no stone unturned in their quest to return to prominence.
Leave a Reply