As the Cincinnati Reds gear up for the season, one of their biggest challenges is sorting out their lineup—or rather, lineups. With a deep and versatile roster, manager David Bell has plenty of moving pieces to consider. But with an abundance of infielders, question marks in the outfield, and a logjam at first base and designated hitter, tough decisions lie ahead. Who plays where? Who gets squeezed out? And who might be ticketed for Triple-A Louisville?
The Infield Congestion
The Reds boast an impressive collection of young infielders, but fitting them all into everyday roles is easier said than done.
- Elly De La Cruz is a lock at shortstop, but his occasional struggles with plate discipline raise questions about whether he’ll stick there full-time.
- Matt McLain showed he belongs in the everyday lineup, likely slotting in at second base when healthy.
- Jonathan India, the 2021 NL Rookie of the Year, faces an uncertain role. With McLain, De La Cruz, and others competing for time in the middle infield, India could see more action at third base or even in a utility role.
- Noelvi Marte is an emerging star, making third base his likely home, assuming the Reds prioritize his development over India’s playing time.
First Base and DH: Too Many Bats, Not Enough Spots
Joey Votto’s departure may have created an opening at first base, but the Reds still have an excess of players who fit best at either first or DH.
- Christian Encarnacion-Strand seems poised to get the bulk of starts at first, but he could also see time at DH.
- Jake Fraley and TJ Friedl, two left-handed bats, could factor into DH at-bats against righties.
- Spencer Steer, after a strong 2023 campaign, will play somewhere—but whether that’s first base, left field, or a hybrid role remains to be seen.
- Jeimer Candelario, a key offseason signing, adds another wrinkle. He has experience at third, first, and DH, making him an essential but tricky piece to place.
Outfield Outlook: Who Gets the At-Bats?
The outfield remains an area of uncertainty, especially with a mix of players who can shift between infield and outfield roles.
- Will Benson showed flashes of breakout potential in 2023 and should see regular playing time in right field.
- TJ Friedl likely starts in center, though platoon considerations could affect his at-bats.
- Jake Fraley remains a reliable bat against right-handers but may sit against lefties.
- Nick Martini and Stuart Fairchild could compete for bench spots, but with so many versatile players, their roles are in question.
Who’s Louisville-Bound?
Not everyone can make the Opening Day roster, meaning some talented young players will begin the season in Triple-A.
- Noelvi Marte may start in Louisville if the Reds want him to get consistent playing time instead of rotating in and out of the lineup.
- Edwin Arroyo, one of the organization’s top shortstop prospects, could also start in Triple-A, awaiting an injury or trade to open up a path.
- Nick Senzel—if he remains with the team—may face an uphill battle for playing time and could be the odd man out.
The Bottom Line
With a wealth of talent and positional flexibility, the Reds have options—but also difficult choices. Balancing development, playing time, and matchups will be a season-long challenge for David Bell. If everything clicks, Cincinnati could have one of the most dangerous and dynamic lineups in the National League. If not, expect plenty of midseason adjustments as they look to find the right combination.
Leave a Reply